“If you’ve got nothing to hide you’ve got nothing to worry about.”
I heard someone say this on the news in support of new remote body scanners being developed for use by police in New York.
Basically, it is infrared scanning technology being used currently at airports and the like to be a “virtual pat-down” to find items hidden on the body like weapons or drugs. Law enforcement is currently funding development of scanners much smaller and more discrete than the frontdoor-sized full body scanners at airports, something that can be used to scan pedestrians in cities without their knowledge.
This in itself isn’t the most appalling violation of privacy I’ve ever heard of before, but when coupled with society’s recent trend toward the abolition of small “insignificant” privacies such as cellphone wire-taps, the obscenely “thorough” pat-downs at airports, or even simply the ubiquitous seeming intrusion of advertising into our homes through facebook, television, or text messaging, it starts to become somewhat of an urgent matter to draw the line somewhere.
Somewhere citizens must take a look down the road and see where it takes us. This road only becomes more and more treacherous as we proceed. As these infractions by law enforcement become more and more commonplace we tend to lose sight of what we had originally considered would be “too much”.
“If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry about.” This is not the answer. Whether or not “Good People” have nothing to worry about is not in question here. I ask that we think about this conceptually. If we consider any breech of privacy to be an infraction the question arises, “When is enough enough?”
Americans, as a pillar of their culture, have a ‘reasonable’ right to privacy, and as a DEMOCRACY, WE have the right to decide how to define the word ‘reasonable’ in this context. Not law enforcement.
Privacy is not only a right to Americans. It is a basic human necessity, as are shelter, and emotional stimulation. It is as important to our existence as Americans as is Security.
In response to the statement, “If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry about.” I say, “To sacrifice any amount of privacy for this sake of security is to sacrifice our humanity for the sake of Judicial and Executive efficiency.”